HomepageISTEEdSurge
Skip to content
ascd logo

Log in to Witsby: ASCD’s Next-Generation Professional Learning and Credentialing Platform
Join ASCD
February 1, 2023
Vol. 80
No. 5
Step By Step

Four Strategies for Vetting Online Lesson Materials

author avatar
author avatar

premium resources logo

Premium Resource

Curriculum
Illustration of a woman looking thoughtfully at a laptop screen
Credit: Good Studio / Shutterstock
All too often we hear stories about low-quality content from the online education resource marketplace TeachersPayTeachers.com (TPT) making their way into students' hands. One study of TPT's top 100 U.S. high school history resources found 70 percent to be of low to moderate quality (Harris et al., 2022). Studies of TPT English language arts, Black history, math, and culturally relevant materials showed similar concerning results (Silver, 2021).
In response, some principals and school districts have banned the use of TPT and similar platforms. But recent research has also shown that these services appear to meet critical needs for teachers, providing places where under-resourced and time-strapped educators connect, exchange ideas, and gain access to needed classroom materials ( Carpenter & Shelton, 2022). So outright bans might not be the best option.
If teachers do use TPT, however, they should be aware of the challenges that can arise when using curriculum that's had limited vetting in open markets (or trying to evaluate TPT resources themselves). As former P–12 educators who research online education resource marketplaces, we have identified four strategies educators should use when seeking out and sharing lesson materials from unvetted online sources.

1. Be Skeptical of Ratings, Tagging, and Popularity Indices

Online marketplaces exist to make money, not necessarily to get the best curriculum into teachers' hands. Don't assume the metrics offered by marketplaces are valid or useful. Although users often rely heavily on TPT buyer reviews (Carpenter & Shelton, 2022), mounting evidence suggests these ratings are almost unanimously high, and therefore uninformative. The credibility of resource tagging has also been questioned—many TPT materials are incorrectly tagged, and over-tagging is widespread. Finally, multiple studies highlight problems with popularity indices, as the most purchased resources are often not high quality (Silver, 2021).

2. Find Trustworthy Sellers and Take Advantage of Online Community

Many teachers value buying material from fellow teachers (Carpenter & Shelton, 2022), but the reality is that many popular TPT sellers operate as small publishing companies. Teachers should investigate content-creators' qualifications, seek out sellers from a diverse array of identities and perspectives, and interrogate sellers' motives and marketing approaches. Ask yourself, "Is there actual pedagogical value in this resource, or am I being swayed by bells and whistles or my desire to keep up with Pinterest-worthy education influencers?" Try using social media to gather recommendations regarding sellers, see examples of how to implement TPT materials, and ask questions of content creators.

3. Look Deeply at Resource Content

When assessing a resource's content, consider coherence and alignment to standards, level of difficulty, copyright, and pedagogical approaches. Work together with your colleagues or department team to collaboratively evaluate material. You might consider the reliability/accuracy of information, the perspectives included (and not included), and opportunities for student agency in the lesson. Avoid assembling a piecemeal curriculum or one that focuses on aesthetics or "engagement."

4. Be Careful with Your Money and Time

Searching for curriculum online can be exhausting and expensive. Ask yourself, "Can I find free (possibly superior) resources elsewhere?" Try exploring vetted, free sources such as Learning for Justice, The New York Times Learning Network, Public Broadcast Station Learning Media, and Smithsonian Learning Lab, among others. Searching among the millions of resources available to teachers demands time and labor, and educators should continually re-evaluate if their methods are worth the effort they require.

A Band-Aid for a Hurting System?

Online education resource marketplaces may in many ways represent a Band-Aid solution for a system in which teachers are too often under-resourced, siloed, overworked, and underpaid. Even experienced teachers may find themselves in moments when using resources from online marketplaces just makes sense. However, when teachers do turn to online curricular sources, they need to exercise caution to make savvy judgements about which resources they use—and how.
References

Carpenter, J., & Shelton, C. (2022). How and why teachers use Teachers Pay Teachers. Journal of Research on Technology in Education, Advanced online publication.

Harris, L., Archambault, L., & Shelton, C. (2022). Issues of quality on Teachers Pay Teachers: An exploration of best-selling U.S. history resources. Journal of Research on Technology in Education, Advanced online publication.

Silver, D. (2022). A theoretical framework for studying teachers' curriculum supplementation. Review of Educational Research.

Catharyn C. Shelton is an assistant professor of educational technology at Northern Arizona University. She was a high school Spanish and special education teacher, and currently teaches educational technology courses at the university level.

Learn More

ASCD is a community dedicated to educators' professional growth and well-being.

Let us help you put your vision into action.
Related Articles
View all
undefined
Curriculum
We Can All Teach Climate Change
Mark Windschitl
7 months ago

undefined
STEM Instruction Can Be a Change Agent!
Natalie Odom Pough
7 months ago

undefined
Bringing a Bold Voice to Mathematics
Rebecca Koenig
7 months ago

undefined
Tell Us About
Educational Leadership Staff
7 months ago

undefined
Bridging Subject-Area Content and Reading Instruction
Beryl Irene Bailey
11 months ago
Related Articles
We Can All Teach Climate Change
Mark Windschitl
7 months ago

STEM Instruction Can Be a Change Agent!
Natalie Odom Pough
7 months ago

Bringing a Bold Voice to Mathematics
Rebecca Koenig
7 months ago

Tell Us About
Educational Leadership Staff
7 months ago

Bridging Subject-Area Content and Reading Instruction
Beryl Irene Bailey
11 months ago
From our issue
February 2023 Header Image
Beyond the Textbook: Content and Curriculum
Go To Publication